So, having found a reliable go-to choc-chip recipe (without having to do the work), I decided it was time to find a standy-by brownie recipe. For years I have been using Chocolate & Zucchini's Melt-in-your-mouth Chocolate Cake as a psuedo-brownie stand-in. It has worked remarkably well with all the variations I've tried (orange, raspberry, walnut, macadamia, caramel peanut), and has become a favourite of my family.
Despite this, I decided to carry on with the search. Having purchased Baked earlier this year, and reading that even Oprah loves their brownies, it seemed a good place to start.
And this is where the wheels fell off.... I made a batch the night before heading to Ireland to visit friends, as a thankyou gift for having us to stay. When I went to package them up I discovered that I had undercooked the middle. Undercooked it so dramatically that it was completely gooey and unusable. No matter, all but the middle third was boxed up and taken away. I froze the rest, figuring inspiration would strike at some stage.
The brownies were delicious and oh-so-rich, especially with the toffee drizzle I added. All were devoured by our lovely Irish friends.
Fast forward to take 2.. I've been reading some positive reviews of the King Arthur Flour Fudge Brownie Recipe. After seeing various comments suggesting that the best way to melt the butter/sugar combo was in a saucepan, this is what I did. Being careful to cook this batch thoroughly (duh), I was really happy with the results. A very rich, fudgey and chewy brownie. This made a full pan plus 12 mini brownie bites, which I iced with chocolate ganache. Yum!
In short, I think the KAF brownie is definitely a winner. I'll make them again, however I'll be sure to make the Baked version again too - as it was entirely my error that caused the earlier disappointment. It all worked out anyway, as the gooey bits are now the star of some vanilla-brownie icecream.